Is Your Farrier a Horseman or a Drug Dealer? Why It Matters.

A farrier should be much more than someone who fits shoes to hooves. They should be a horseman—a professional who can read a horse’s body language, communicate effectively, and respond to challenges with skill and patience rather than force or sedation. Too often, however, farriers default to sedation when confronted with a horse that doesn’t immediately comply, potentially creating a dangerous cycle of dependency and mistrust.

Horsemanship is the foundation of safe farrier work

Understanding the Issue

Over the past several months, I’ve repeatedly heard clients say, “My horse has to be sedated to be shod.” In 99% of these cases, this isn’t true. The horse doesn’t need sedation—it needs a horseman. Somewhere along the way, a farrier likely bypassed the opportunity to build trust and understanding with the horse. Instead of taking the time to address the root of the behavior, they reached for sedation or force as a quick fix.

While sedation may seem like an easy solution, it can mask underlying issues. Is the horse reacting out of fear? Pain? A lack of training? Without addressing these questions, the behavior will persist—and often worsen over time.

When is Sedation Truly Necessary?

To be clear, there are valid reasons to sedate a horse during farrier work. These include:

Pain management for medical conditions like laminitis or abscesses.
Severe discomfort due to injury or chronic ailments.
Legitimate safety concerns when a horse poses an immediate threat to itself or the handler.

However, these cases are rare. Most horses labeled as “requiring sedation” need something else entirely: trust, training, and partnership. These come from a collaboration between the owner, the farrier, and the horse.

The Risks of Repeated Sedation

Relying on sedation as a crutch rather than a last resort carries serious long-term consequences for the horse:

Muscle damage (myopathy): Repeated use of sedatives can result in diminished muscle function over time.
Nerve damage (neuropathy): Prolonged immobility during sedation can cause nerve compression injuries.
Increased risk of fractures: Sedated horses often lose proprioception (their sense of where their body is in space), making sudden movements dangerous.
Prolonged recovery times: Regular sedation slows down a horse’s ability to bounce back after procedures.
Increased anesthetic sensitivity: Over time, a horse’s body can develop adverse reactions or increased reliance on sedatives.

Horsemanship as the Solution

The best farriers are horsemen first. They understand that patience and skill can often replace drugs and force. A true horseman builds trust with the horse, taking the time to assess its personality, learn its triggers, and earn its cooperation.

Owners play a vital role, too. Investing in training and handling between farrier visits can make all the difference. When the owner, farrier, and horse work together, the results are safer, more successful shoeing sessions and a more confident, trusting horse.

Ask Yourself

Would you rather rely on drugs to handle your horse, knowing the risks, or invest the time and effort to build trust through horsemanship, patience, and training?

The answer is simple. When horsemanship leads the way, everyone benefits: the horse, the owner, and the farrier.